What is a custody hearing in Brazil and what does the judge decide?
By Felipe Mendes Smargiassi, lawyer · OAB/MG 155.242 · Published
It is the hearing where a judge reviews an arrest made in the act, within 24 hours. Since 2026 it is held by videoconference, with the arrested person, their lawyer or the public defender, and the prosecutor. The crime is not tried there: the judge annuls an illegal arrest, grants provisional release, with or without bail, or orders pre-trial detention.
The criminal defense is conducted by Felipe Mendes Smargiassi himself, a criminal defense lawyer (OAB/MG 155.242).
What to do now
- Find out where the person is held and whether the hearing has already taken place.
- Appoint a lawyer before the hearing: the law guarantees a private interview between the arrested person and their lawyer, by video too.
- If the person is a foreign national, ask for their consulate to be informed.
- Gather what helps the judge decide on release: ID, address, job, ties to Brazil or the reason for the trip.
- If the hearing has passed and the person is still in prison, the defence can ask the judge to revoke the pre-trial detention.
- Write to a lawyer in Brazil with the full name, date of birth, city of the arrest and what you know.
What the law says
- The arrest and the place of detention are reported at once to the judge, the prosecutor and the family or a person the arrested person names; within 24 hours the arrest record goes to the judge and, if no lawyer is named, to the Public Defender (Code of Criminal Procedure, art. 306, caput and § 1).
- Within 24 hours of the arrest the judge holds the custody hearing by real-time videoconference, with the arrested person, their lawyer or the Public Defender, and the prosecutor (art. 310, caput, as worded by Law 15.358/2026).
- At the hearing the judge, in a reasoned decision, annuls an illegal arrest, converts it into pre-trial detention, or grants provisional release, with or without bail (art. 310, I, II and III).
- Before the hearing the arrested person has the right to a private interview with their lawyer, in person, by video or by any other means (art. 310, § 9). An in-person hearing is allowed only in cases of force majeure, by reasoned decision (§ 13).
- Anyone who does not speak Portuguese is heard through an interpreter (art. 193).
- If a foreign national asks, the authorities inform their consulate without delay; the consulate may visit them and help arrange their defence (Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, art. 36).
Official sources (text of the law, in Portuguese)
- Código de Processo Penal (Decreto-Lei 3.689/1941), arts. 193, 306, 310 e 316
- Lei 15.358/2026 (nova redação do art. 310 do CPP)
- Convenção de Viena sobre Relações Consulares (Decreto 61.078/1967), art. 36
Accessed on .
The firm does not promise release, deadlines or outcomes: the judge decides each case.
Questions
Does the lawyer have to be from the city where the person was arrested?
No. A lawyer registered with the Brazilian Bar (OAB) may practise anywhere in the country (Law 8.906/1994, art. 7, I), and Brazilian criminal proceedings are electronic. The custody hearing, held within 24 hours of the arrest, takes place by real-time videoconference (Code of Criminal Procedure, art. 310, as amended by Law 15.358/2026): the lawyer takes part from wherever he is. For jury trials and in-person hearings, the lawyer travels to the court. If something requires physical presence on the same day, the firm brings in a colleague at that court, by delegation of powers (substabelecimento), and remains responsible for the case. What matters in choosing is that the lawyer practises criminal defense, takes up the case on the same day and speaks to the family in its own language.
Does the custody hearing decide whether the person is guilty?
No. The judge only reviews the arrest: whether it was lawful and whether the person awaits trial in prison or at liberty. The facts are argued later, in the criminal case.
Is it held in person or by video?
By real-time videoconference, since Law 15.358/2026. In person only in exceptional cases of force majeure, by reasoned decision of the judge (art. 310, § 13). If the connection fails on the court's side, the whole hearing is repeated (§ 11).
What if the judge ordered pre-trial detention?
The defence can ask the judge to revoke it when the reasons for it no longer exist (art. 316). The judge must in any case review whether it is still needed every 90 days (art. 316, sole paragraph).
Is there time to appoint a lawyer from abroad?
Often, yes: the family can instruct the lawyer remotely, and the interview with the arrested person can take place by video (art. 310, § 9). The sooner the lawyer is appointed, the more the judge gets to see.
Other pages
- Relative arrested in Brazil now
- Interpol red notice and extradition from Brazil
- Residence in Brazil: retirees, digital nomads, investors and family
- Recognition of a foreign divorce or judgment in Brazil
- A correspondent in Brazil for your firm
- CPF for foreigners: the Brazilian taxpayer number
- Criminal record certificate in Brazil
- Overstayed your visa in Brazil
- Administrative services in Brazil
- Brazilian consulates: what they do
- Buying property in Brazil as a foreigner
- Opening a company in Brazil as a foreigner
- Family reunification in Brazil
- Marrying a Brazilian
- Brazilian naturalisation
- All pages in English
Felipe Mendes Smargiassi is a lawyer in Brazil, registered with the Brazilian Bar (OAB/MG) under no. 155.242. He practises Brazilian law and is not registered with any bar or law society of another country.How to verify a lawyer in Brazil
- OAB/MG 155.242, admitted in 2014
- Postgraduate studies in Criminal Procedure (Faculdade Legale)
- Guaxupé (MG), practice throughout Brazil
Write to us
Tell us briefly about your case. A lawyer from the firm replies by email, usually within one business day.
How to hire from abroad
- You tell us about the case by WhatsApp, in a message or a voice note, or by e-mail, in English.
- The fee is agreed in a written contract before any work begins.
- The contract and the power of attorney are signed online, and payment can be made from abroad.
How to check a lawyer in Brazil
- Look up the OAB registration in the National Registry of Lawyers (cna.oab.org.br).
- Ask for the fee in writing, in a contract.
- Pay only in the name of Felipe Mendes Smargiassi. Nothing is received in the name of third parties, and any other contact using his name is not his.
OAB/MG 155.242, cna.oab.org.br · How to check a lawyer in Brazil · Google ★
When a person answers
The office answers in person Monday to Friday, 8 am to 6 pm Brasília time (UTC-3).
WhatsApp receives messages at any time.
Arrest or custody hearing: the office attends around the clock. For other matters, the lawyer usually replies within one business day.
Page reviewed in November 2026.