Can a foreigner convicted in Brazil serve the sentence in their home country?
By Felipe Mendes Smargiassi, lawyer · OAB/MG 155.242 · Published
Yes, through the transfer of sentenced persons. A person convicted in Brazil may be transferred to the country of nationality, or to the country of habitual residence or of a personal tie, to serve the rest of the sentence, when there is a treaty or a promise of reciprocity and the person expresses the wish to go (Migration Law, Law 13.445/2017, art. 103). The judgment must be final, at least one year of the sentence must remain, the act must be a crime in both countries and both countries must agree (art. 104).
Arrest or custody hearing: the office attends around the clock. Write or send a voice message on WhatsApp at any hour, in English.
Prefer to write? Email us
Most clients abroad write to us. Email crosses time zones and keeps a record. Documents can go by email or through the contact form (PDF, JPG or PNG, up to 10 MB). We reply in English, usually within one business day (we are in Brazil, UTC−3).
The requirements
The convicted person is a national of the other country, or has habitual residence or a personal tie there that justifies the transfer; the judgment is final; at least one year of the sentence remains to be served on the date of the request; the act is a crime under the law of both countries; the convicted person, or their representative, agrees; and both countries agree (Law 13.445/2017, art. 104; Decree 9.199/2017, art. 293).
If there is no final judgment yet, the request is put on hold until the conviction becomes final (Decree 9.199/2017, art. 293, § 2).
Who decides and who can ask
The Ministry of Justice and Public Security processes and authorises transfers, in coordination with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Decree 9.199/2017, art. 285, § 3).
The request can be made by the convicted person or by any person or authority, Brazilian or foreign, who knows that the person wants to be transferred (art. 292).
What changes after the transfer
Once the person is handed over, the receiving country takes over the enforcement of the sentence under its own law, including the grounds on which the sentence is extinguished, unless a treaty provides otherwise (Decree 9.199/2017, arts. 286 and 288). The receiving country may not make the sentence harsher (art. 289, sole paragraph).
The transfer may come with a ban on re-entering Brazil (Law 13.445/2017, art. 103, § 2). There is no transfer when extradition would not be admitted (art. 105, § 2).
Official sources (text of the law, in Portuguese)
- Lei de Migração (Lei 13.445/2017), arts. 103 a 105
- Decreto 9.199/2017 (regulamento da Lei de Migração), arts. 285 a 289, 292 e 293
Accessed on .
General information on Brazilian law, from the text of the law. Each request depends on the treaty with the country, the facts and the decision of the authorities.
Frequently asked questions
Can the transfer be requested before the trial ends?
The request can be filed, but it is put on hold until the conviction is final (Decree 9.199/2017, art. 293, § 2).
Does the prisoner have to agree?
Yes. The law requires the convicted person, or their representative, to express the wish to be transferred (Law 13.445/2017, arts. 103, § 1, and 104, V).
Which law governs the sentence afterwards?
The law of the receiving country, including the grounds on which the sentence is extinguished, unless a treaty provides otherwise; that country may not make the sentence harsher (Decree 9.199/2017, arts. 288 and 289).
Felipe Mendes Smargiassi is a lawyer in Brazil, registered with the Brazilian Bar (OAB/MG) under no. 155.242. He practises Brazilian law and is not registered with any bar or law society of another country.How to verify a lawyer in Brazil
- OAB/MG 155.242, admitted in 2014
- Postgraduate studies in Criminal Procedure (Faculdade Legale)
- Guaxupé (MG), practice throughout Brazil
Write to us
Tell us briefly about your case. A lawyer from the firm replies by email, usually within one business day.
How to hire from abroad
- You tell us about the case by WhatsApp, in a message or a voice note, or by e-mail, in English.
- The fee is agreed in a written contract before any work begins.
- The contract and the power of attorney are signed online, and payment can be made from abroad.
How to check a lawyer in Brazil
- Look up the OAB registration in the National Registry of Lawyers (cna.oab.org.br).
- Ask for the fee in writing, in a contract.
- Pay only in the name of Felipe Mendes Smargiassi. Nothing is received in the name of third parties, and any other contact using his name is not his.
OAB/MG 155.242, cna.oab.org.br · How to check a lawyer in Brazil · Google ★
When a person answers
The office answers in person Monday to Friday, 8 am to 6 pm Brasília time (UTC-3).
WhatsApp receives messages at any time.
Arrest or custody hearing: the office attends around the clock. For other matters, the lawyer usually replies within one business day.